Power tools often look similar on the surface, yet small details set them apart in performance and practicality. Makita has built a strong reputation for reliability, and two of their most popular reciprocating saws, the XRJ04Z and XRJ05Z, stand out for different reasons. Both models deliver impressive cutting power, but their features speak to slightly different types of users.
The XRJ04Z offers straightforward strength and durability, making it an excellent pick for those who prioritize raw cutting ability without extra bells and whistles. Its design leans toward simplicity, giving users confidence in heavy-duty jobs where consistency matters most.
The XRJ05Z, on the other hand, introduces added versatility with a brushless motor that boosts efficiency and extends tool life. This model caters to users who want advanced technology paired with performance, reducing maintenance needs while improving battery run time.
Contractors, DIY enthusiasts, and professionals often debate which one deserves a spot in the toolkit. By breaking down design, performance, comfort, and value, it becomes easier to see how each saw fits different working styles. The choice isn’t about which model is better overall but about which one matches the demands of your projects most effectively.
Makita XRJ04Z vs XRJ05Z Cordless Recipro Saw
Cordless reciprocating saws make cutting jobs much faster and easier. Makita offers two popular models: the XRJ04Z and the XRJ05Z. Both are built for power, speed, and user comfort, but they are not the same. Let’s look at each one in detail before comparing them side by side.
Makita XRJ04Z Cordless Recipro Saw
Product Details
The Makita XRJ04Z comes with a strong variable speed motor that delivers up to 2,800 strokes per minute. It has a 1-1/4 inch stroke length, which makes it suitable for cutting wood, metal, and other materials.
A tool-less blade change system helps users replace blades quickly. The saw is 19-1/8 inches long and weighs 8.3 pounds with a battery. The compact design makes it easier to control during longer tasks.
Features
-
Variable speed motor: 0–2,800 strokes per minute
-
Stroke length: 1-1/4 inch
-
Tool-less blade change system
-
Compact and ergonomic design at 19-1/8 inches
-
Weight: 8.3 lbs. with battery (not included)
What is the Good?
The XRJ04Z provides reliable cutting performance at a steady speed. The variable speed trigger allows better control depending on the material. Its lightweight build reduces hand fatigue. Blade changes are quick and easy. The design is simple, making it a practical choice for regular cutting jobs.
What is the Bad?
It does not have a brushless motor, which means less efficiency compared to newer models. The saw is slightly longer than some other cordless options, which can be an issue in tight workspaces. It is sold as a bare tool, so the battery and charger need to be purchased separately.
Overall Opinion
The XRJ04Z is a dependable choice for those who need a straightforward reciprocating saw. It delivers solid performance and is easy to handle. While it lacks advanced motor technology, it still gets the job done well for most users.
Makita XRJ05Z Brushless Cordless Recipro Saw
Product Details
The Makita XRJ05Z uses a brushless motor with two-speed settings: 0–2,300 strokes per minute on low and 0–3,000 on high. Like the XRJ04Z, it has a 1-1/4 inch stroke length for efficient cutting.
A tool-less blade change system makes replacing blades faster. The saw measures 17-1/4 inches long and weighs 8.2 pounds with a battery. It comes with a 6-inch 6TPI reciprocating saw blade in the box.
Features
-
Brushless variable 2-speed motor: 0–2,300 (low) & 0–3,000 (high) SPM
-
Stroke length: 1-1/4 inch
-
Tool-less blade change system
-
Compact and ergonomic design at 17-1/4 inches
-
Weight: 8.2 lbs. with battery (not included)
-
Includes a 6″ 6TPI reciprocating saw blade
What is the Good?
The XRJ05Z offers more efficiency due to its brushless motor. The two-speed settings make it versatile for different materials and applications. It is shorter than the XRJ04Z, making it easier to use in tight spaces. The included blade is a helpful addition, so users can start right away.
What is the Bad?
The XRJ05Z costs more than the XRJ04Z, which may not fit every budget. While the brushless motor provides better performance, the difference might not be noticeable for lighter, casual work. Like the XRJ04Z, it is sold without a battery or charger.
Overall Opinion
The XRJ05Z is a more advanced and efficient version of the XRJ04Z. Its brushless motor, compact size, and two-speed settings make it a strong choice for users who need better control and durability. It is a step up for professionals and those who do heavy cutting often.
Details Comparison Makita XRJ04Z vs XRJ05Z
Both saws share a similar stroke length and quick blade change system, but they differ in design and motor technology. The XRJ04Z is longer at 19-1/8 inches and slightly heavier at 8.3 lbs., while the XRJ05Z is shorter at 17-1/4 inches and lighter at 8.2 lbs.
The XRJ04Z uses a standard motor with a top speed of 2,800 strokes per minute. The XRJ05Z has a brushless motor with two-speed options, reaching up to 3,000 strokes per minute for faster cuts.
The brushless motor also means more efficiency, longer runtime, and reduced wear. For tight spaces and heavy-duty tasks, the XRJ05Z has the edge. For basic jobs at a lower cost, the XRJ04Z is still a reliable tool.
FAQs
Q1: Do these saws come with batteries?
No, both are sold as bare tools. You need to buy the battery and charger separately.
Q2: Can both models cut wood and metal?
Yes, both can cut wood, metal, and other materials. The blade type determines the exact cutting ability.
Q3: Which model is better for tight spaces?
The XRJ05Z is shorter and easier to handle in small areas.
Q4: Is the brushless motor worth the extra cost?
For heavy or frequent use, yes. It gives better efficiency, speed, and durability. For light work, the XRJ04Z may be enough.
Q5: Do both models use the same Makita 18V batteries?
Yes, both are part of Makita’s 18V LXT line and are compatible with the same batteries.
Conclusion
The Makita XRJ04Z and XRJ05Z are both strong cordless reciprocating saws. The XRJ04Z offers a solid and affordable option for basic cutting.
The XRJ05Z, with its brushless motor and compact design, gives more efficiency and better control. For casual jobs, the XRJ04Z is a good pick. For professionals or demanding tasks, the XRJ05Z is the smarter choice.
